Log in

No account? Create an account
Unbelievable... - Antony Fedorov [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Antony Fedorov

[ website | American Idol ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Unbelievable... [Apr. 28th, 2005|01:58 pm]
Antony Fedorov
[mood |pissed offpissed off]
[music |"This Is How you Remind Me" by Nickelback]

In case you were wondering, because I know I sure as Hell was, it was no coincidence that Constantine Maroulis, a fan favorite was suddenly kicked off last night, and Scott Savol, the fan's least favorite, was suddenly out of the bottom three where he had been for weeks, displacing not only Constantine, but also another favorite, Vonzell Solomon.

How did this happen?


Basically, there is a campaign against the show American Idol to prove what a joke it is. They have picked who they think the worst contestant is:

And now they are trying to get everyone to vote for him, and get him to be the next American Idol, thinking that if they do, they'll be able to prove the show is a sham. Wow, great joke.

This is completely unfair to the actually talented contestants on the show who do deserve to go far, and to win.

In other words? We have to stop this.

And we can.

Scott has been in the bottom three consistently until this happened, so if we all pitch in on Tuesday, and vote more than ever for our favorite contestants, we could still get him kicked off. Now, I represent the Carrie community, but I'm still a big Bo, Vonzell, and Anthony fan as well.

And for all of the Constantine fans, what happened so wasn't fair. But are you going to let Constantine's whole American Idol journey be in vain? Are you going to let this sabotage succeed? Scott should have left, not Constantine. So this Tuesday night, still vote. Vote for Carrie, Bo, Vonzell, or Anthony, and show those people who's little joke got Constantine kicked off American Idol too early, who's really laughing now.

This is ridiculous, people! American Idol may be a joke to some people, but we end up loving the contestants, so this Tuesday, we all have to vote like it was the finale, and each one of these contestants was about to be the next American Idol.

I'm going to throw in a couple of votes for all of the idols this time.

All of them, except for Scott.

Fawn - Moderator/Creator of carrieunderwood

x-posted to Carrie, Bo, Vonzell, & Anthony Communities

[User Picture]From: samantha_may
2005-04-28 07:03 pm (UTC)
I'm a fan of Anthony, and so is Scott's. Just because he doesn't have the looks does not mean he's not good. Did it ever occur to people that the reason Scott didn't get voted off this week is because he's better than Constantine? It's not fair to jump into conclusion that Scott is overall the worst contestant just because he's been in the bottom three pretty consistently.

If we want to talk about American Idol being unfair, there's no end to it. When the favorite gets voted off, the fans get angry. When the least favorite gets voted off, other fans also get angry. Either way, people still lose and win.
(Reply) (Thread)
From: cookiexdough
2005-04-28 11:03 pm (UTC)
It has nothing to do with Scott's looks, which is funny that you immediately jumped to that conclusion.

I have thought, since day one, that Scott Savol, is a completely weak, completely uninspired singer, who barely passes as anything more than a karaoke level singer, as Randy Jackson has been insinuating for weeks. I disregard Scott on the basis that he is in a competition with several people who are real, true, amazing, incredible vocalists, and he barely holds a candle to that.

And yes, looks wise, he's the most lacking in that department, but that has nothing to do with it or my personal disdain for him.

But the basis of my whole argument, is that voting for him just to prove the competition is a joke, is not funny, or not a valid thing to do, and we should be more persistent in voting for our favorites.

And no, it never occured to me that he didn't get voted off because he's better than Constantine, because he's not. a) You're the first person I've ever met who's admitted to liking Scott and/or voting for him, and b) Simon Cowell is the authority, and he's been telling Scott to pack his bags for weeks, while his praise for Maroulis has steadily increased. I take an industry professional's opinion over any internet fan's opinion any day.

(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
From: mystery_sparky
2005-05-01 06:44 am (UTC)


i agree, i was surprised that he got more votes than the other three contestants in the bottom three, putting vocals aside *which he does okay in) he isn't that good looking, and he is boring to watch on stage, there are three things you need in order to get th most votes, in my opinion, you need to have the voice, the look, and the presence

i didnt know about that sham but it would eplain a lot if it is true, i wasnt a big fan of consantine's but Vonzell is definately far better than Scott is in every category
(Reply) (Thread)